Chronic Absenteeism and the “Five Why’s”: Stop Chasing Symptoms and Start Tackling Solutions

Chronic Absenteeism and the “Five Why’s”:

Stop Chasing Symptoms and Start Tackling Solutions

Listen to a summary and analysis of this Blog on the Improving Education Today: The Deep Dive podcast—now on the Better Education (BE) Podcast Network.

Hosted by popular AI Educators Angela Jones and Davey Johnson, they provide enlightening perspectives on the implications of this Blog for the Education Community.

[CLICK HERE to Listen on Your Favorite Podcast Platform]

(Follow this bi-monthly Podcast to receive automatic e-mail notices with each NEW episode!)

[CLICK HERE to Set Up a Meeting with Howie]

Dear Colleagues,

Introduction: Chronic Absenteeism is Not New

   A late July 2025 District Administration article identified the “Top 5” education challenges today according to 2,500 teachers, administrators, and leaders surveyed by PowerSchool.

   Education’s #1 Challenge: “Promoting School Attendance.”

   Somewhat ironically, as I began to research this article, I found publications on my computer hard-drive discussing the extent and impact of chronic absenteeism in schools well before 2010.

   So, it appears that chronic absenteeism has been a chronic problem in our nation’s schools for quite a while.

_ _ _ _ _

   But to provide context: Nationally, students are considered chronically absent when they miss 10% or more of the school year—excused, unexcused, or even suspended. For a 180-day school year, this means roughly 18 days out of school.

   And right now, the numbers are still staggering.

   Before COVID, the national absenteeism rate hovered in the mid-teens—about 15 to 16% of all students. Fast-forwarding to the 2021–22 post-COVID school year, the U.S. Department of Education reported nearly 14.7 million students were chronically absent. That’s about 30% of the entire K–12 population—double the pre-pandemic levels, and 6.5 million more absent students than just a few years earlier.

   The next 2022-2023 school year brought only modest improvements: 28% of students nationwide were chronically absent. That means more than one in four children across America missed nearly a month of school that year.

   Finally, a recent August 14, 2025 RAND report, summarizing selected American School District and Youth Panel surveys, estimated the 2024–2025 school year’s chronic absenteeism rate at 22%—involving 2.8 million students.

   And while White students accounted for the largest number of chronically-absent students, chronic absenteeism is disproportionately concentrated among our most vulnerable groups: Students from low-income families, Black and Hispanic youth in many districts, English learners, children with disabilities, and Native American and Pacific Islander students.

   Geographically, while urban school districts saw sharp increases in absenteeism rates, suburban and rural schools haven’t been spared. Indeed, the above Rand Report noted that, in roughly half of urban school districts, more than 30% of students were chronically absent. But some suburban and rural districts also had more than 30% of their students missing three-plus weeks of school per year.

   Clearly, all of the data above point to a national education emergency that is directly undermining much of what the school and schooling process is trying to accomplish—academic proficiency. And is it any surprise that our national NAEP scores continue to drop?

   And the research is clear: Chronic absenteeism cannot be viewed only as a “student problem” that simply needs to be documented and tracked through non-compliance letters.

   Student absences are tied to sociological and ecological factors like family stability, transportation, health care, mental health, and student engagement—issues that extend beyond the classroom walls.

   Thus, effective educational leaders need to establish multi-factored strategies: Investing in real-time attendance tracking, forging community partnerships for health and transportation, supporting staff who build daily relationships with families, and using data to identify which schools (and which students) need the most immediate attention.

   But, let’s not get ahead of ourselves.

You Have to Name It Before You Solve It: The Five “Why’s”

   A May 9, 2025 District Administration Leadership Institute White Paper (“Before You Solve It, You Have to Name It”) noted:

(We) advocate for deep problem diagnosis as a method to equip superintendents, senior leaders, and boards with practical tools and processes to confront today’s realities. We argue that superintendents will spend increasing amounts of time looking and engaging outward. Only then will they be ready to turn inward to activate the tools that turn the knowledge they’ve gained into actionable strategies. This executive leadership will require both windows—outward—and mirrors—inward. By understanding and applying these tools, superintendents can lead their districts with resilience, legitimacy, and political capital.

   Said a different way:

• Complex educational problems require multi-dimensional ecological analyses—assessing the community, families, district, schools, peer groups, and individual students—that differentially recognize and assess their root causes.
• Chronic absenteeism is a symptom. The real problems to tackle are the legitimate and validated (using objective data) root causes.
• By definition, this means that different communities, families, districts, schools, peer groups, and individual students will have different root causes.
• Hence, to solve these (root cause) problems, a strategic number of multi-layered, interdependent solutions (i.e., services, supports, strategies, and/or interventions) will be needed.

   As suggested by the District Administration article, it often takes “five why’s” to get to a root cause. The initial layers of the root cause analysis may use, for example, (a) “traditional” methods like data dashboards that cross-analyze the different process and outcome indicators related to chronic absenteeism; and (b) flexible Plan-Do-Study-Act cycles that allow for prototype testing and mid-course adjustments.

   But, simultaneously, the “Five Whys” technique, developed by Toyota founder Sakichi Toyoda, should be employed.

   By repeatedly asking “Why?” (five times is typical, but not a rule), educational leaders dig below surface-level symptoms to understand the deeper reasons (or Fishbone “spurs”) for complex issues.

   Example and Problem: Why are students absent from school?

• Why? Because some are feeling academically unsuccessful at school, and it’s easier to avoid—rather than confront—this reality.
• Why? Because they do not have the academic prerequisite skills to do the grade-level work.
• Why? Because they did not learn many of these prerequisite skills during the pandemic, virtual instruction year. Thus, these students had skill-deficits, before experiencing motivation-deficits.
• Why? Because the administration is requiring teachers to teach grade-level work, and they are not pre-assessing students’ prerequisite skill abilities.
• Why? Because teachers are not strategically teaching (some do not believe they have “permission” to do this) their students’ most-missing prerequisite skills within their grade-level instruction. Moreover, the school does not have the support systems or services (computer labs, virtual tutoring, after-school buses) to help students close broader academic skill gaps.

   Note the underlined some in the first bullet above. This thread represents just one (multi-dimensional) root cause explaining a school’s chronic absenteeism challenge.

A Sampling of Chronic Absenteeism Root Causes

   A recent August 28, 2025 Education Week article summarized some recent reasons and beliefs that students and parents have about missing school.

   The results revealed:

• Illness (67%) was the most common reason students identified for missing school in the August RAND survey. Other reasons included feeling down or anxious (10%), oversleeping (9%), and being uninterested in attending (7%). About 4% said they missed school to care for a family member, 3% lacked transportation to school, and 1% reported work conflicts.

A June, 2024 NPR/Ipsos poll noted that parents most often identified illnesses and concerns for student safety as acceptable reasons for them to miss school. 51% of the parents surveyed said that some sort of illness was a valid reason to stay home (even when their children were not contagious and had no fever).

Some experts believe we have so emphasized (especially during the pandemic) NOT coming to school when you feel ill, that students and parents have become over-sensitized to this.

_ _ _ _ _

• Most of the parents in the NPR/Ipsos poll failed to correctly define chronic absenteeism. Indeed, 51% said that a student was chronically absent when they miss at least 20% of the school year—twice the national standard.

Applying this definition, 58% of the parents identified chronic absenteeism as a major problem, and yet they often underestimated their own children’s absences.

_ _ _ _ _

• In the Rand study, 25% of the surveyed students did not think that missing three or more weeks of school in a single academic year was a problem.

Critically, student responses did not vary by gender, ethnicity, or age. However, students whose parents had a high school degree or less were more likely to say that missing three weeks of school is “mostly OK” (33%), than peers whose parents had some college experience (24%).

_ _ _ _ _

   Clearly, there is an individual story—or collection of stories—behind every absence.

   Recognizing the survey results above, and using additional Five Why’s approaches, some additional chronic absenteeism root causes include:

     Community or Family-Reasons

• Poverty and housing instability: Families facing eviction, homelessness, or frequent moves often can’t maintain consistent school attendance.
• Transportation barriers: Lack of reliable public transit, family vehicles, or long unsafe walking routes prevents students from getting to school.
• Parental work schedules: Parents working multiple jobs or nonstandard hours may struggle to get children to school regularly.
• Childcare responsibilities: Older siblings, particularly in low-income households, may stay home to care for younger children.
• Food insecurity and basic needs: Hunger and lack of clean clothes deter some students from attending.
• Community violence or unsafe neighborhoods: Safety concerns discourage families from sending children out the door.
• Cultural or language barriers: Families new to the U.S. may be unaware of attendance requirements or struggle to navigate school systems.
• Immigration Status: Immigrant or families of color may keep students home due to threats or fear of being detained or deported, for example, by ICE.

_ _ _ _ _

     District or School-Related Reasons

• Negative school climate: Schools where students feel unwelcome, unsafe, or unvalued see higher absenteeism.
• Inconsistent enforcement of discipline: Suspensions, punitive attendance policies, exclusion, and disproportionate discipline practices push students out.
• Weak family-school communication: Poor outreach or lack of proactive engagement leads families to underestimate absence consequences.
• Limited access to school-based services: If schools lack health clinics, mental health supports, or special ed resources, students with needs often miss more days.
• Transportation provided by district is unreliable: Late buses, long routes, or service gaps cause chronic missed days.
• Academic disengagement: A curriculum that feels irrelevant or unchallenging reduces motivation to attend.
• Overcrowding or underfunding: Schools without resources for individualized support fail to catch early absence patterns.

_ _ _ _ _

     Peer-Related Reasons

• In-person/social media bullying and harassment: Victims of peer aggression often avoid school to escape mistreatment.
• Peer pressure: Friends normalize skipping or cutting class, making absence more socially acceptable.
• Exclusion from peer groups: Students who feel socially isolated may withdraw by not attending.
• Gang involvement or unsafe peer groups: Association with peers outside of school often pulls students away from classes.
• Peer aggression or microaggression: Peer conflicts factor into school avoidance.
• Shifting peer culture: In some schools, chronic absence itself becomes normalized within certain student groups.

_ _ _ _ _

   Individual Student Reasons

• Chronic health conditions: Asthma, diabetes, and other medical issues remain leading causes of missed school.
• Mental health challenges: Anxiety, depression, stress, and trauma contribute significantly to prolonged absence.
• Substance use: Emerging in middle and high school, this can interfere with daily functioning and attendance.
• Academic struggles: Students who are behind in reading or math may avoid school to escape embarrassment or hopelessness.
• Disability-related barriers: Lack of accommodations or poor IEP implementation leads to inconsistent attendance.
• Lack of motivation or engagement: A belief that school is irrelevant to future goals drives disengagement.
• Fear of failure or performance anxiety: Some students avoid testing days or classes where they feel overwhelmed.
• Sleep issues: Particularly among adolescents, circadian rhythm changes, late-night device use, or unstable routines cause oversleeping and missed school.

The Hidden Costs of Absence

   Any discussion of chronic absenteeism must include cost-analyses of what happens when students are gone for stretches of time and then inconsistently return to their classrooms.

   Academics. The first and most obvious cost involves the academic progress of the chronically-absent students themselves.

   These students miss significant amounts of instructional time, classroom discussion, and guided practice, and they have less time and opportunity to master the material when they show up.

   The result is that they often fall behind in core content, they do not fully learn the skills that are foundational to learning the “next” set of skills, and they eventually become frustrated and disengaged. Research clearly shows that chronic absenteeism strongly predicts lower test scores, grade retention, and ultimately, decreased graduation rates.

_ _ _ _ _

   Instruction. But a related cost is to the teachers who are often hard-pressed to cover required amounts of material—even when all of their students are present.

   When chronically-absent students finally show up, teachers must sacrifice the core instructional time for their consistently-attending students in order to catch their chronically-absent students up on previously-taught material.

   To further compound this problem, note that different chronically-absent students in the same class may show up on different days.

   The net result here is that teachers become trapped in a cycle of starting and restarting lessons, instructional momentum becomes inconsistent and may be lost, and teachers become frustrated and demoralized. Research has shown that teachers whose classes had higher absenteeism rates in the Fall semester expressed less job satisfaction, feelings of usefulness, and belief in the teaching profession.

_ _ _ _ _

   Peer Impact. Consistently-attending students often mirror their teachers as they become frustrated by the redundant instruction, the diluted curriculum, and their disrupted learning. At times, they begin to tune out or, worse, start missing classes themselves.

   From a peer perspective, a related cost is the social-emotional relationship cost. Chronically absent students miss peer-to-peer bonding opportunities. This not only weakens the sense of belonging that research shows is critical to motivating their attendance, but it also cuts them off from relationships that make learning possible—especially when teachers use cooperative or project-based group learning strategies.

   Students who feel disconnected are less likely to return, and consistently-attending students may not have the relationships with them that facilitate everyone’s learning.

_ _ _ _ _

   In short, chronic absenteeism has pervasive effects on absent students, present students, instructional integrity, academic outcomes, social-interpersonal dynamics, and classroom climate.

   But, once again, to solve (or prevent) the overarching problem, solutions need to be connected with root causes.

Evidence-Based Interventions to Address Chronic School Absenteeism

   The multifaceted nature of chronic absenteeism requires comprehensive, multi-tiered interventions that selectively address the community, school, peer, and individual root causes.

   Current research emphasizes the importance of preventive approaches, early identification systems, and wraparound services that support both students and families. Effective interventions must be culturally responsive, trauma-informed, and implemented with fidelity across all stakeholder levels.

   The following evidence-based strategies provide a framework for systematically addressing the complex web of factors contributing to students’ chronic absenteeism.

   Community and Family Supports and Interventions

• Targeted Home Visit Programs: Deploy trained attendance specialists to conduct structured home visits within 3 to 5 days of chronic absence identification, using motivational interviewing techniques and family-specific barrier assessments.
• Housing Stability Partnerships: Establish formal MOUs with local housing authorities to prioritize stable housing for school-age families and to provide 30-day advance notice of potential moves to allow school transition planning.
• Emergency Transportation Fund: Create rapid-response transportation assistance including Uber/Lyft vouchers for medical appointments, temporary bus passes during family vehicle repairs, and emergency ride services for students in crisis situations.
• Wraparound Resource Navigation: Assign dedicated family resource coordinators to chronically absent families who conduct comprehensive needs assessments and provide direct connections to specific services (food assistance, utility support, childcare) within 48 hours.
• Immigrant Family Safe Harbor Protocols: Implement district-wide policies explicitly prohibiting sharing student information with immigration authorities and provide annual "Know Your Rights" workshops conducted by immigration attorneys.
• Alternative Childcare Solutions: Partner with local childcare centers to provide emergency drop-in care for siblings during school hours and establish on-site childcare during parent conferences and school events.
• Community Safety Escorts: Coordinate with community organizations to provide trained volunteer walking escorts for students in high-crime areas, particularly during early morning and after-school hours.

   _ _ _ _ _

   District and School Supports and Interventions

• Tiered Attendance Response Protocol: Implement automated daily absence alerts with specific intervention triggers: 3-day absence = phone call, 5-day = home contact, 10% threshold = formal attendance team meeting with family within one week.
• Alternative Schedule Accommodations for Chronically Absent Students: Offer late-start options (10:00 AM start time), compressed four-day schedules, or flexible credit-bearing independent study for students with documented family work obligations or chronic health conditions.
• Mobile Health Services: Deploy school nurse visits to homes of chronically absent students with health conditions, coordinate telehealth appointments during school hours, and provide medication management support through school-based health centers.
• Trauma-Informed Classroom Modifications: Train teachers to implement specific accommodations for chronically absent students including flexible assignment deadlines, alternative testing locations, and reduced sensory stimulation options.
• Family Communication Technology Upgrades: Utilize multilingual automated calling systems with attendance-specific messaging, two-way texting platforms for real-time family communication, and mobile app notifications for daily attendance tracking.
• Attendance Recovery Programming: Establish Saturday school or after-school programs specifically for chronically absent students to make up instructional time while addressing underlying barriers through integrated support services.
• Transportation Reliability Improvements: Install GPS tracking on buses with real-time family notifications, provide backup transportation for students with documented chronic absence due to bus issues, and offer flexible pickup/drop-off locations.

   _ _ _ _ _

   Peer-Related Supports and Interventions

• Chronic Absence Peer Mentoring: Match chronically absent students with trained peer mentors who have successfully improved their own attendance, providing weekly check-ins and social support strategies.
• Targeted Social Skills Groups: Conduct small-group interventions (4 to 6 students) focused on social anxiety, conflict resolution, and peer relationship building specifically for chronically absent students struggling with peer interactions.
• Restorative Practices for Attendance Issues: Use circle processes specifically designed to address attendance-related peer conflicts and rebuild classroom community connections for returning chronically absent students.
• Anti-Bullying Intensive Support: Provide immediate safety planning and daily check-ins for chronically absent students with documented bullying experiences, including schedule modifications and supervised peer interactions.
• Digital Citizenship Intervention: Offer specialized cyberbullying support including social media monitoring assistance for families and digital relationship repair strategies for affected students.
• Inclusive Re-entry Support: Create structured re-engagement protocols for chronically absent students returning to school, including peer buddy assignments and gradual social reintegration planning.
• Positive Peer Culture Development: Implement attendance ambassador programs where students with good attendance provide non-judgmental support and celebration for peers working to improve attendance.

   _ _ _ _ _

   Individual Supports and Interventions for Chronically Absent Students

• Comprehensive Attendance Assessment: Conduct individualized evaluations using validated tools (e.g., School Refusal Assessment Scale-Revised) to identify specific functions of absence behavior and tailor interventions accordingly.
• Medical Absence Case Management: Assign health coordinators to students with chronic health conditions who help develop 504 plans with attendance accommodations, coordinate with healthcare providers, and provide in-school medical support.
• Mental Health Intensive Services: Provide weekly individual counseling sessions for chronically absent students with anxiety or depression, implement cognitive-behavioral interventions for school refusal, and offer crisis intervention protocols.
• Academic Recovery Planning: Create individualized learning plans that allow chronically absent students to demonstrate mastery through alternative assessments, project-based learning, and competency-based progression rather than seat-time requirements.
• Sleep Disorder Intervention: Partner with local sleep clinics to provide evaluations for chronically absent students with sleep issues, educate families on adolescent sleep needs (8.5 to 9.5 hours per night), and implement school start time accommodations when possible.
• Substance Use Screening and Support: Conduct confidential substance use screenings for chronically absent middle and high school students and provide immediate connections to age-appropriate treatment programs.
• Motivation Enhancement Protocols: Use structured motivational interviewing sessions to help chronically absent students identify personal values and goals connected to education, developing individualized "reasons to attend" portfolios.
• Gradual Re-engagement Plans: Implement systematic return-to-school protocols for severely chronically absent students, starting with partial days, specific preferred classes, or alternative learning environments before transitioning to full-day attendance.
• Executive Functioning Support: Provide organizational skills training, time management coaching, and daily planning assistance specifically for chronically absent students with attention or learning difficulties.
• Crisis Response Planning: Develop individualized crisis plans for chronically absent students with trauma histories, including safe spaces, trusted adult contacts, and de-escalation strategies.
• Attendance Self-Monitoring Systems: Teach chronically absent students to track their own attendance patterns, identify personal triggers for absence, and implement self-advocacy strategies.

Summary: Breaking the Cycle of Chronic Absenteeism Through Strategic Leadership

   Chronic absenteeism has reached crisis proportions in American schools, with current data showing that 22% of students—approximately 2.8 million children—are missing 10% or more of the school year. This represents a devastating educational emergency that extends far beyond individual student challenges, creating cascading effects that undermine classroom instruction, teacher effectiveness, and the learning environment for all students.

   The research is unequivocal: when chronically absent students sporadically return to class, teachers must repeatedly restart lessons, consistently attending students experience diluted instruction, and the entire educational ecosystem becomes disrupted. The hidden costs include not only academic regression for absent students, but also decreased job satisfaction among educators, and social-emotional gaps that perpetuate the cycle of disengagement.

   The root causes of chronic absenteeism are complex and multifaceted, requiring educational leaders to move beyond surface-level symptoms to conduct deep diagnostic analyses. Using the "Five Whys" methodology, we discover that attendance problems stem from interconnected challenges spanning community factors (poverty, housing instability, transportation barriers), school-related issues (negative climate, academic disengagement, inadequate support services), peer dynamics (bullying, social isolation, normalized absence culture), and individual student needs (mental health challenges, chronic health conditions, academic struggles). Current survey data reveals alarming gaps in understanding, with many parents incorrectly defining chronic absenteeism, and students failing to recognize the severity of missing three or more weeks of school annually.

   Effective intervention requires comprehensive, evidence-based strategies that directly address these identified root causes through coordinated multi-tiered support systems. Community and family interventions must include targeted home visits within 3 to 5 days of chronic absence identification, emergency transportation funds, wraparound resource navigation, and immigrant family safe harbor protocols.

   At the district and school level, leaders must implement tiered attendance response protocols with specific intervention triggers, alternative scheduling accommodations, mobile health services, and trauma-informed classroom modifications.

   Peer-related supports should focus on chronic absence peer mentoring, targeted social skills groups, and structured re-engagement protocols, while individual interventions must include comprehensive attendance assessments using validated tools, intensive mental health services, and gradual re-engagement plans tailored to each student's specific barriers.

   The path forward demands that school leaders recognize chronic absenteeism not as a student compliance issue, but as a symptom of deeper systemic challenges requiring strategic, data-driven responses. Success depends on implementing coordinated interventions that address the ecological factors contributing to absence patterns while simultaneously building supportive relationships and removing barriers to consistent attendance. This necessitates forging community partnerships, and ensuring that staff are equipped with the tools and training needed to conduct root cause analyses and implement targeted interventions with fidelity.

_ _ _ _ _

Call to Action: The Transformation Must Begin Today

   The time for incremental change has passed—our students need bold, immediate action. As educational leaders, we cannot afford to treat chronic absenteeism as “just another problem,” or rely on outdated punitive approaches that push our most vulnerable students further away from school. We lose 2.8 million students to disengagement, academic failure, and diminished life opportunities each day that comprehensive, evidence-based interventions are missing.

   Educational Leaders need to conduct "Five Why’s" analyses with their attendance data. Identify the specific root causes affecting your chronically absent students, and then immediately implement the best-linked supports and interventions from the discussion above.

   Partner with community organizations, establish tiered response protocols, train your staff in stress- and trauma-informed practices, and create the wraparound support systems that transform your school's attendance culture.

   Concerted and consistent leadership in this critical moment will determine whether our chronically-absent students become statistics or success stories.

Our Improving Education Today Podcast is Part of the Better Education (BE) Network of Top Education Podcasts in the U.S.

   Remember that our Podcast . . .

Improving Education Today: The Deep Dive

with popular AI Educators, Davey Johnson and Angela Jones. . . is a full member of the Better Education (BE) Network of the top podcasts in education in the country!

This means that our Podcast is now available not just on Spotify and Apple, but also on Overcast, Pocket Casts, Amazon Music, Castro, Goodpods, Castbox, Podcast Addict, Player FM, Deezer, and YouTube.

Here's how you can sign up to automatically receive each new episode:

LINK HERE: Improving Education Today: The Deep Dive | Podcast on Spotify

LINK HERE: Improving Education Today: The Deep Dive | Podcast on Apple Podcasts

LINK HERE for All Other BE Education Network Platforms: Improving Education Today: The Deep Dive | Podcast on ELEVEN More Podcasts

Twice per month, Davey and Angela summarize and analyze the “real world” implications of our Project ACHIEVE bi-monthly Blog messages—adding their unique perspectives and applications on their relevance to you and our mission to: Improve Education Today.

These Podcasts address such topics as: (a) Changing our Thinking in School Improvement; (b) How to Choose Effective School-Wide Programs and Practices; (c) Students’ Engagement, Behavioral Interactions, and Mental Health; and (d) Improving Multi-Tiered and Special Education Services.

Davey and Angela have also created a Podcast Archive for all of our 2024 Blogs (Volume 2), and the most important 2023 Blogs (Volume 2).

They will continue to add a new Podcast each time a new Project ACHIEVE Blog is published.

Many districts and schools are using the Podcasts in their Leadership Teams and/or PLCs to keep everyone abreast of new issues and research in education, and to stimulate important discussions and decisions regarding the best ways to enhance student, staff, and school outcomes.

If you would like to follow up on today’s Blog or Podcast, contact me to schedule a free one-hour consultation with me and your team.

[CLICK HERE to Set Up a Meeting with Howie]

I hope to hear from you soon.

Best,

Howie

[CLICK HERE to Set Up a Meeting with Howie]

[To listen to a synopsis and analysis of this Blog on the “Improving Education Today: The Deep Dive” podcast on the BE Education Network: CLICK HERE]